
Idaho is one of the safest states in the country, and its crime numbers are still falling. Statewide, reported Group A offenses dropped 7% last year to 66,889, Idaho State Police figures show.
Crime is not spread evenly, though, and a few cities report rates well above the rest of the state. The ranking below comes from HomeSnacks. Its analysts took FBI crime data for 2024, looked at 30 Idaho cities above 5,000 residents, ranked each on violent and property crime per capita, and averaged the two.
“Worst” here refers only to crime rates. It says nothing about jobs, schools, housing or anything else that makes a place worth living in.
1. Garden City
This small city surrounded by Boise takes the top spot. Garden City’s 12,956 residents saw 656 violent crimes per 100,000 people, the highest rate on the list, and 1,436 property crimes per 100,000. That works out to roughly a 1 in 47 chance of becoming a crime victim.
2. Pocatello
Pocatello, with 58,618 people, logged 341 violent crimes and 1,587 property crimes per 100,000. Property crime is the main problem here, since only Chubbuck posts a higher property rate in the top ten.
3. Idaho Falls
Eastern Idaho’s largest city, home to 68,716 people, recorded 357 violent and 1,209 property crimes per 100,000, along with three murders.
4. Twin Falls
Twin Falls, population 55,932, had a violent crime rate of 417 per 100,000 and a property rate of 1,126, plus three murders.
5. Chubbuck
Chubbuck’s violent crime rate is fairly low, but its property crime rate is far above any other city here. The Pocatello suburb of 16,600 reported 2,687 property crimes per 100,000 against just 265 violent crimes. Its total crime rate tops the whole table, and only the lower violent number keeps it in fifth.
6. Caldwell
Caldwell, with 71,115 residents, posted 453 violent crimes per 100,000 and 977 property crimes, with one murder. Its violent crime rate is the third highest in the top ten, behind Garden City and Rupert.
7. Boise
The state capital makes the list largely because of property crime. Boise’s 235,223 residents experienced 294 violent and 1,110 property crimes per 100,000, and the city recorded three murders.
8. Rupert
Rupert is the smallest city on the list, and its violent crime rate is second only to Garden City’s. The Magic Valley town of 6,399 reported 641 violent crimes per 100,000 but only 750 property crimes. In a town this small, a few incidents can move the rate a lot.
9. Payette
Payette, population 8,790, came in at 296 violent crimes and 990 property crimes per 100,000, with no murders.
10. Lewiston
Lewiston rounds out the list with the lowest violent crime rate of the ten, 191 per 100,000, though property crime ran higher at 1,313 among its 35,036 residents.
Keep the Numbers in Perspective
Three things are worth remembering before judging any of these cities:
- Idaho’s baseline is low. One analysis puts the state’s crime rate 55% under the national average and ranks Idaho second-safest among the 50 states.
- Small towns swing widely. Rupert and Payette have fewer than 9,000 residents each, so a few extra cases in one year can change their rates sharply.
- Rankings depend on method. A different ranking that includes towns as small as 1,000 people puts Shoshone first, ahead of Garden City and Rupert.
If you are thinking of moving to one of these cities, look at neighborhood-level data and talk to people who live there. A citywide rate does not tell you much about a particular street.
Sources :
- https://www.homesnacks.com/most-dangerous-cities-in-idaho/
- https://cdapress.com/news/2026/jul/30/report-idaho-crime-decreased-in-2025/