Florida Man Accused of Mailing Peanut Butter-Smeared Card to Woman With Life-Threatening Allergy

A 68-year-old Florida man has been arrested on charges that he mailed a greeting card smeared with peanut butter to his ex-wife’s best friend, knowing she has a severe peanut allergy. Police say he blamed her for his divorce.

Joseph Gerard Cancellare Jr., of Plantation, is charged with aggravated battery with a deadly weapon and culpable negligence.

A Greasy Blue Envelope

According to a probable cause affidavit, the woman was collecting her mail in August 2025 when she noticed a blue envelope that looked greasy. Inside was a greeting card with a brown substance on it, which she recognized as peanut butter.

The woman, described in the affidavit as “deathly allergic,” dropped the envelope and ran inside to wash her hands. Police said she broke out in hives on both arms and felt a tingling sensation for about six hours.

How Police Say They Traced It

Investigators found that the “Forever” stamps on the envelope had been bought at a self-service kiosk at the Davie Post Office about a week before the card arrived.

Police allege Cancellare paid for the stamps with his own credit card. The kiosk also took a photo of the buyer’s face, and the woman recognized him immediately when detectives showed it to her, the affidavit says.

Twenty Years of Dinners Together

The woman told police she has known Cancellare for 20 years because he was married to her best friend. She described the divorce as contentious and said he largely blamed her for it.

She said he would certainly have known about her allergy, since the two couples had eaten out together many times. At every meal she warned the restaurant that she could not come into contact with peanuts, peanut oil or anything cross-contaminated.

She told investigators she can react through touch, by eating peanuts or even through the air, and that a reaction could kill her without immediate treatment.

Investigators wrote that she acted quickly to protect her life when she opened the envelope. They noted she was still visibly distressed when she gave her statement more than a year later.

She said she had last seen Cancellare about three years before the incident, when she was present as an observer while the former couple divided their property under the divorce settlement.

Where the Case Stands

Police arrested Cancellare on Friday and booked him into the Broward County Jail. He has since posted bond, and no court date has been listed.

He has been charged but not convicted, and the allegations have not been tested in court.

Source

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top